Creating Space for Constructive Conversations about Money with Family
November is a month associated with starting to hear Christmas music. But for me, as a financial planner, my attention gets drawn to another phenomenon that happens this time of year.
It’s this little rule that gets more airtime around the holidays because of the increase in family time. That rule? You’re not supposed to talk about three things at family gatherings: politics, religion, and money.
I’m not here to pick apart this whole faux pas. But I am here to ask a question to reframe the thinking behind it. If we can’t talk about money with family, the people we should trust and care about most, then with whom can we talk about it?
So, Should Money Conversations with Family Be Completely Off-Limits?
Now, I’m not saying that every money topic should be on the metaphorical table. No, that’s a bad idea. But by continuing to treat the entire subject of money as off-limits, our families don’t develop a shared understanding of what it means to each of us. And like the critters this time of year, we stash away our money struggles, questions, and fears like little nuts. Although we’re trying to keep the peace, sometimes we’re just deferring an issue and making it bigger. You see, not communicating about our problems doesn’t resolve those problems. And the feelings behind those problems, especially ones like resentment, thrive under these conditions.
You might be nodding your head in agreement that there are money topics that can and should be addressed with family. At the same time, you might feel equally consumed by dread. How would you even start a conversation about money with family, much less a productive one? That’s what brings me to you. I want to share three ways to ease into these conversations with family without blurting out a half-baked thought at the dinner table.
Starting Simple with Money: A Family Sharing Exercise
Just like you don’t do the Turkey Trot 5k after finishing your Thanksgiving meal, there’s an order that makes sense for creating a space in your family to talk productively about money. You have to start small to build the trust and lay the groundwork for future, deeper conversations.
One way we have seen clients successfully do this is to blend gifting with paying it forward. Instead of giving to a charity of your choice as a parent or grandparent, you can give a set amount of money to your children or grandchildren to spend on themselves. The only stipulation is that they must then give a portion of that gift to a cause they care about. After giving, they write you a letter about why they chose that cause, what they learned, and how it made them feel. It creates more connection with you and your loved ones than a check or cash gift ever would have revealed.
While I use this as an illustrative example of creating a space of sharing, something like this may not be feasible in every family. But other ways to share don’t require quite as much work. It can be a simple question at the dinner table when the conversation dies down:
- What’s the most rewarding thing you did with your money this year?
- What was a joy experiment you tried with your money? (If you need ideas, we did a whole series of these with our advisors at Pleasant Wealth; you can find it on my YouTube Channel).
- What was your favorite experience someone else provided to you this past year?
Like the living legacy exercise, these questions can tease out parts of our family members’ personalities that we may not have known. It also creates another important habit: recognizing others’ contributions to our experiences.
Learning from Each Other: Imparting Money Lessons
That leads us right to the next money conversation starter. Instead of talking about ourselves, one of the best ways to foster an engaged conversation is to ask others to talk about themselves.
It’s no secret that people usually enjoy talking about themselves. And there’s another interesting paradoxical component at play. People tend to like us more when we ask them a favor than when we do something for them. So the idea here is to ask a favor of others at the table. Have them impart the wisdom they have about something tied to money. This can take the form of many different questions, some that don’t necessarily involve using the word “money”:
- What’s the biggest lesson you have learned about your money?
- If you could go back and tell your younger self one lesson, what would it be?
- If money wasn’t an object, what career would you have liked to pursue?
Our families contain many unique experiences. This helps us discover stories we may not know. At the same time, we’re sourcing advice from elders (or even family members around the same age) to help in our own journey.
Gently Opening the Door to Important Conversations
So far, I’ve talked about conversations that work in a group setting, but I also want to capture one area suited to more private, one-on-one moments. As adults, how do we build a relationship with a parent that includes money?
Well, we don’t start in the room. We first have to open the door. This starts with the questions I mentioned in the previous section, and then can expand into more delicate conversations. I know not every family dynamic supports this. Not to mention, generational differences shape how we even view money. But we may be able to make small inroads.
This is especially top of mind for me after recently having a conversation on the Insight Series about traumatic loss. The guest in the interview segment is a mental health counselor, someone well-equipped for challenging moments and conversations. But she still had her world shaken to its core by the loss of her husband to suicide. She raised several profound points about death that mirror our relationship with money. One of these was that, although we’re all going to die, we’re terrified to talk about death. The same can be true of our money. It’s such a crucial piece of our lives, and yet, we don’t talk about it.
Again, you can’t just jump into the conversation about a parent’s biggest fears about money or death. But you can gently open the door to those deeper conversations one question at a time. Many others have experienced and written about this, so instead of providing questions in this section, I invite you to explore what others have created.
- Tell me your story: There are a number of these journaling exercises out there (like this one) where you and a parent (or really any family member) slowly work through their story together. It’s a wonderful shared experience and an entry point that gives them space to open up to you.
- Caring for a parent with dementia: I mentioned the sandwich generation earlier, and the unfortunate reality for many in this group is that they’re caring for an aging parent. As dementia or Alzheimer’s sets in, it’s really difficult to connect with the person you know and love who’s being masked by their cognitive decline. This is a really profound piece about how to do that by tapping into your parent’s memories and passions.
I won’t pretend to know everything on this subject, so if you’ve found other resources helpful in your journey with an aging parent, I’d love it if you shared them with me. We’re all in this together.
Do You Want to Feel Better about Your Money?
While I hope this piece has helped you start to wrap your mind around money conversations, it’s only the first step. So many experiences shape our relationship with money, and that relationship is mirrored in countless parts of our lives.
At the end of the day, our driving force at Pleasant Wealth is to help our clients feel better about money. That journey is more than meeting once a year with a financial advisor. If you’d like to explore how our approach might align with your money, I’d invite you to schedule a time to meet and get to know each other.
About the Author
Liz Hand, CFP®, ACC, is a financial advisor and certified coach who focuses on serving women approaching or already in retirement. She shares complex financial ideas in practical terms and is passionate about helping women build confidence alongside their wealth.

